How Many Miles?
  • Home
  • Journey
    • Journey walking my way to fitness

      Walking My Way To Fitness

      June 1, 2025

      Journey Road to Success

      The Olympic Road To Success With adidas

      July 1, 2024

      Journey

      The End of the Road For How Many Miles?

      September 29, 2019

      Journey

      Can I get fit with PJG Online Personal Training?

      March 18, 2019

      Journey

      Best Laid Plans – Never Give Up and Never Give In

      September 9, 2018

  • Try-Athlete
    • All Commonwealth Games #Team14 DoMore with Strathmore Free Events Kit and Tech Reviews Radio
      Journey Road to Success

      The Olympic Road To Success With adidas

      July 1, 2024

      Kit and Tech Reviews

      Sit Stand Desk Guide for On Your Feet Britain Day with Sit-Stand.Com

      April 26, 2018

      Free Events LetsMoveforabetterworld

      Join Me For a Free Workout with #LetsMoveForaBetterWorld

      March 25, 2018

      Health

      Win a Naipo Massage Cushion

      February 19, 2018

      Commonwealth Games #Team14

      Do More Child’s Play

      October 2, 2014

      Commonwealth Games #Team14

      Libby’s Guide to Running

      September 3, 2014

      Commonwealth Games #Team14

      Team14 & Team Scotland Commonwealfies

      August 17, 2014

      Commonwealth Games #Team14

      People Made Glasgow 2014

      August 9, 2014

      DoMore with Strathmore Paralympic Hope

      Scotland’s Paralympic Hopes in Rio 2016

      August 28, 2016

      DoMore with Strathmore

      Do More Child’s Play

      October 2, 2014

      DoMore with Strathmore

      Libby’s Guide to Running

      September 3, 2014

      DoMore with Strathmore

      Can’t Swim, Won’t Swim with Robbie Renwick

      June 26, 2014

      Free Events LetsMoveforabetterworld

      Join Me For a Free Workout with #LetsMoveForaBetterWorld

      March 25, 2018

      Free Events Never Stop Glasgow

      Get Fit For Free with NeverStopGlasgow and The North Face

      October 1, 2016

      Free Events

      Get Fit For Free in Glasgow (and Balloch).

      August 30, 2016

      Kit and Tech Reviews Road to Success

      The Olympic Road To Success With adidas

      July 1, 2024

      Kit and Tech Reviews

      Sit Stand Desk Guide for On Your Feet Britain Day with Sit-Stand.Com

      April 26, 2018

      Kit and Tech Reviews

      Win a Naipo Massage Cushion

      February 19, 2018

      Kit and Tech Reviews

      Treadmill or Dreadmill: The Technogym SkillMIll Review

      January 22, 2018

      Radio

      CamGlen Radio Does Zumba in Glasgow

      August 4, 2016

      Radio

      Don’t Worry, Be Happy

      June 3, 2016

      Radio Hampden Sports Clinic

      Can I Run? My question to Hampden Sports Clinic.

      May 4, 2016

      Radio

      CamGlen Radio’s Adventure Show TryBowls

      April 7, 2016

  • Triathlon
    • All Cycling Running Swimming
      Physical Activity Swimathon 2023

      Swimathon 2023-A Big Swim for Big Swim Day

      February 24, 2023

      Swimming Swimathon

      Everything is Going Swimmingly with Swimathon

      April 3, 2022

      Physical Activity TRI in the Park

      Can’t Open Water Swim , WILL Open Water Swim with TRI in the Park

      July 4, 2018

      Cycling Mountain Bike Guide

      Take Me to the Hills- A Beginners Guide to Mountain Biking

      June 1, 2018

      Cycling Mountain Bike Guide

      Take Me to the Hills- A Beginners Guide to Mountain Biking

      June 1, 2018

      Cycling

      Bike Light Guide from Cycle Republic

      December 29, 2017

      Cycling What to Wear on Cycle to Work Day

      What to Wear on Cycle to Work Day?

      September 11, 2017

      Cycling Cycle to Work

      What you need to Cycle to Work (my 5 month “expert’ advice).

      July 13, 2017

      Running

      Treadmill or Dreadmill: The Technogym SkillMIll Review

      January 22, 2018

      Running

      I’m Back with a Glasgow Men’s 10K Review

      June 18, 2017

      Running

      The Bishopbriggs Sprint Triathlon Review

      May 8, 2017

      Running

      End Great Run Herbalife Partnership

      April 22, 2017

      Swimming Swimathon 2023

      Swimathon 2023-A Big Swim for Big Swim Day

      February 24, 2023

      Swimming Swimathon

      Everything is Going Swimmingly with Swimathon

      April 3, 2022

      Swimming TRI in the Park

      Can’t Open Water Swim , WILL Open Water Swim with TRI in the Park

      July 4, 2018

      Swimming

      Swimathon Masterclass and Interview with Keri-Anne Payne

      January 30, 2018

  • Travel
    • All Asia Australia Europe North America
      Europe Italy for Active Holidays

      The Best Destinations in Italy for Active Holidays

      August 11, 2024

      Europe Three green activities in Greece

      Three green activities in Greece to add to your sustainable itinerary

      June 16, 2024

      Asia Guide to Mountain Trekking in Nepal

      Guide to Mountain Trekking in Nepal

      May 18, 2024

      Travel Guide to Antarctica Expeditions

      Guide to Antarctica Expeditions

      May 18, 2024

      Asia Guide to Mountain Trekking in Nepal

      Guide to Mountain Trekking in Nepal

      May 18, 2024

      Asia Mumbai

      Mumbai- The City That Stole Our Hearts

      November 28, 2016

      Australia Noosa National Park

      Best of Queensland : A walk in Noosa National Park

      August 21, 2016

      Australia

      Best of Queensland : Glasshouse Mountains Walk

      August 14, 2016

      Australia

      Salty Dog Sea Kayaking in the Whitsundays

      July 26, 2016

      Australia Fraser Island Tour

      Fraser Island Tour with Fraser Explorer Tours

      July 18, 2016

      Europe Italy for Active Holidays

      The Best Destinations in Italy for Active Holidays

      August 11, 2024

      Europe Three green activities in Greece

      Three green activities in Greece to add to your sustainable itinerary

      June 16, 2024

      Europe fitness holidays in france

      The Best Destinations for Fitness Holidays in France

      May 18, 2024

      Europe Fitness holidays in Portugal

      The Best Destinations for Fitness Holidays In Portugal 

      May 3, 2024

      North America TWA Hotel

      TWA Hotel, NYC. A View to a Thrill

      July 27, 2023

  • FSEM Lay View
  • British Medical Journal Blog
  • Home
  • Journey
    • Journey walking my way to fitness

      Walking My Way To Fitness

      June 1, 2025

      Journey Road to Success

      The Olympic Road To Success With adidas

      July 1, 2024

      Journey

      The End of the Road For How Many Miles?

      September 29, 2019

      Journey

      Can I get fit with PJG Online Personal Training?

      March 18, 2019

      Journey

      Best Laid Plans – Never Give Up and Never Give In

      September 9, 2018

  • Try-Athlete
    • All Commonwealth Games #Team14 DoMore with Strathmore Free Events Kit and Tech Reviews Radio
      Journey Road to Success

      The Olympic Road To Success With adidas

      July 1, 2024

      Kit and Tech Reviews

      Sit Stand Desk Guide for On Your Feet Britain Day with Sit-Stand.Com

      April 26, 2018

      Free Events LetsMoveforabetterworld

      Join Me For a Free Workout with #LetsMoveForaBetterWorld

      March 25, 2018

      Health

      Win a Naipo Massage Cushion

      February 19, 2018

      Commonwealth Games #Team14

      Do More Child’s Play

      October 2, 2014

      Commonwealth Games #Team14

      Libby’s Guide to Running

      September 3, 2014

      Commonwealth Games #Team14

      Team14 & Team Scotland Commonwealfies

      August 17, 2014

      Commonwealth Games #Team14

      People Made Glasgow 2014

      August 9, 2014

      DoMore with Strathmore Paralympic Hope

      Scotland’s Paralympic Hopes in Rio 2016

      August 28, 2016

      DoMore with Strathmore

      Do More Child’s Play

      October 2, 2014

      DoMore with Strathmore

      Libby’s Guide to Running

      September 3, 2014

      DoMore with Strathmore

      Can’t Swim, Won’t Swim with Robbie Renwick

      June 26, 2014

      Free Events LetsMoveforabetterworld

      Join Me For a Free Workout with #LetsMoveForaBetterWorld

      March 25, 2018

      Free Events Never Stop Glasgow

      Get Fit For Free with NeverStopGlasgow and The North Face

      October 1, 2016

      Free Events

      Get Fit For Free in Glasgow (and Balloch).

      August 30, 2016

      Kit and Tech Reviews Road to Success

      The Olympic Road To Success With adidas

      July 1, 2024

      Kit and Tech Reviews

      Sit Stand Desk Guide for On Your Feet Britain Day with Sit-Stand.Com

      April 26, 2018

      Kit and Tech Reviews

      Win a Naipo Massage Cushion

      February 19, 2018

      Kit and Tech Reviews

      Treadmill or Dreadmill: The Technogym SkillMIll Review

      January 22, 2018

      Radio

      CamGlen Radio Does Zumba in Glasgow

      August 4, 2016

      Radio

      Don’t Worry, Be Happy

      June 3, 2016

      Radio Hampden Sports Clinic

      Can I Run? My question to Hampden Sports Clinic.

      May 4, 2016

      Radio

      CamGlen Radio’s Adventure Show TryBowls

      April 7, 2016

  • Triathlon
    • All Cycling Running Swimming
      Physical Activity Swimathon 2023

      Swimathon 2023-A Big Swim for Big Swim Day

      February 24, 2023

      Swimming Swimathon

      Everything is Going Swimmingly with Swimathon

      April 3, 2022

      Physical Activity TRI in the Park

      Can’t Open Water Swim , WILL Open Water Swim with TRI in the Park

      July 4, 2018

      Cycling Mountain Bike Guide

      Take Me to the Hills- A Beginners Guide to Mountain Biking

      June 1, 2018

      Cycling Mountain Bike Guide

      Take Me to the Hills- A Beginners Guide to Mountain Biking

      June 1, 2018

      Cycling

      Bike Light Guide from Cycle Republic

      December 29, 2017

      Cycling What to Wear on Cycle to Work Day

      What to Wear on Cycle to Work Day?

      September 11, 2017

      Cycling Cycle to Work

      What you need to Cycle to Work (my 5 month “expert’ advice).

      July 13, 2017

      Running

      Treadmill or Dreadmill: The Technogym SkillMIll Review

      January 22, 2018

      Running

      I’m Back with a Glasgow Men’s 10K Review

      June 18, 2017

      Running

      The Bishopbriggs Sprint Triathlon Review

      May 8, 2017

      Running

      End Great Run Herbalife Partnership

      April 22, 2017

      Swimming Swimathon 2023

      Swimathon 2023-A Big Swim for Big Swim Day

      February 24, 2023

      Swimming Swimathon

      Everything is Going Swimmingly with Swimathon

      April 3, 2022

      Swimming TRI in the Park

      Can’t Open Water Swim , WILL Open Water Swim with TRI in the Park

      July 4, 2018

      Swimming

      Swimathon Masterclass and Interview with Keri-Anne Payne

      January 30, 2018

  • Travel
    • All Asia Australia Europe North America
      Europe Italy for Active Holidays

      The Best Destinations in Italy for Active Holidays

      August 11, 2024

      Europe Three green activities in Greece

      Three green activities in Greece to add to your sustainable itinerary

      June 16, 2024

      Asia Guide to Mountain Trekking in Nepal

      Guide to Mountain Trekking in Nepal

      May 18, 2024

      Travel Guide to Antarctica Expeditions

      Guide to Antarctica Expeditions

      May 18, 2024

      Asia Guide to Mountain Trekking in Nepal

      Guide to Mountain Trekking in Nepal

      May 18, 2024

      Asia Mumbai

      Mumbai- The City That Stole Our Hearts

      November 28, 2016

      Australia Noosa National Park

      Best of Queensland : A walk in Noosa National Park

      August 21, 2016

      Australia

      Best of Queensland : Glasshouse Mountains Walk

      August 14, 2016

      Australia

      Salty Dog Sea Kayaking in the Whitsundays

      July 26, 2016

      Australia Fraser Island Tour

      Fraser Island Tour with Fraser Explorer Tours

      July 18, 2016

      Europe Italy for Active Holidays

      The Best Destinations in Italy for Active Holidays

      August 11, 2024

      Europe Three green activities in Greece

      Three green activities in Greece to add to your sustainable itinerary

      June 16, 2024

      Europe fitness holidays in france

      The Best Destinations for Fitness Holidays in France

      May 18, 2024

      Europe Fitness holidays in Portugal

      The Best Destinations for Fitness Holidays In Portugal 

      May 3, 2024

      North America TWA Hotel

      TWA Hotel, NYC. A View to a Thrill

      July 27, 2023

  • FSEM Lay View
  • British Medical Journal Blog

How Many Miles?

Try Athlete and Active Traveller

HealthObesity

My View on Activity Equivalents proposals from RSPH

written by Stephen Morrison April 18, 2016
BJSM Blog

Gove’s Intentions

In 2014, Michael Gove, the then Minister of Education , suggested that schools should use traditional punishments to discipline malcontent and miss behaving school pupils (1).

One of the suggested punishments for classroom indiscipline was running laps of the playground.

Not only could this be viewed as a form of corporal punishment, outlawed across the UK by 2003 (2), but for the overweight and inactive it could even be regarded as cruel and unusual punishment.

The sport that I love (and occasionally hate) touted as a means of reprimanding rebellious kids. Lanes replacing lines and exhaustion replacing detention. It earmarked running as a punishment and children would arguably soon learn to despise running.

Athletic champions such as Chrissie Wellington, now Head of Participation at parkrun, and head teachers quickly and quite rightly slammed these proposals (3) and thankfully this idea never got off the mark.

Gove’s intentions might have been good, but he had not properly considered the consequences of his proposal.

 

Good Intentions

Now, in 2016, we have proposals to combat obesity and inactivity that seem to have good intentions.

The Royal Society of Public Health have recommended that activity equivalents should be printed on food packaging (4) and the Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health have urged, in the BMJ, for a ban on televisions from children’s bedrooms (5).

I seem to be one of a small band of dissenters voicing my disbelief at the thought of printing activity equivalents on food labels  as a means of combating obesity.

And I question just how much consideration has been given to those who are overweight or obese.

As the RSPH video below shows, the general consensus is that this is a good idea and part of me tried to understand their reasoning.

The rationale is that it could act as a deterrent. Would I consume less of my favourite caramel wafers if I knew that I would need to run twenty minutes to burn one off?

Would I think twice about that second helping of pie if I had to run 3.14159 miles?

The answer is no. My overconsumption of food wasn’t/isn’t caused by a lack of awareness of nutritional guidelines or values.

I have psychological urges to eat. I seek comfort in food and the cost of that comfort is not as important as the immediate need to feed.

When I eat a family bag of sweets, there is no part of me that believes I am within the calorific limits of my daily basal metabolic rate. I eat in full knowledge of the long term harm of my actions. I like to think that I am relatively intelligent. I just make irrational choices and I binge eat.

It is not an excuse, but this is the mindset of many obese people. 

Printing activity equivalents on food might appeal to and help people who are consciously making efforts to improve their health, such as members of the Nuffield Gym featured in the video, but I am not convinced that it would greatly influence the obese or inactive.

However, there is a danger that it could reinforce negative associations with food and contribute to eating disorders. Back to using exercise as a punishment and even as a reward. For me, these concerns outweigh (no pun intended) the possible impact varying physiologies and metabolisms have on the accuracy of the printed activity equivalents.

My Faculty of Sport and Exercise Medicine post on Salutogenis (6) highlights how complex socio-economic and societal factors can affect behaviour and decision making while my post on active children (7) hopefully shows why banning televisions in children’s rooms, as proposed by JECH, fails to consider more important barriers preventing children from being more active.

Removing televisions might reduce screen time, but how does this then automatically lead to kids being more active and eating less junk? Do these researchers genuinely believe that this will result in families eating together?

Do they realise that there is so much more to the disintegration of family meal times than televisions in bedrooms?

Correlation does not necessarily mean causation.

And again, we are looking to apply punitive action. We are making children and families feel guilty, rather than looking at the other barriers that prevent families from dining together.

As my friend, Rannoch Donald, often proclaims, it’s never one thing. We need to stop looking at ideas in isolation and we need to look at the bigger picture.

We need, as I state in my recent BMJ Blog (8), to take action and implement the recommendations that the Obesity Stakeholder Group (9) call for, rather than trying to devise new headline grabbing but ultimately flawed ideas.

Good intentions do not necessarily mean good ideas.

Extra Reading

1) http://www.theguardian.com/education/2014/feb/02/michael-gove-traditional-punishments-school-misbehaviour
2) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/School_corporal_punishment#United_Kingdom
3) http://www.politics.co.uk/news/2014/02/24/michael-gove-slammed-for-punishing-children-with-sport
4) https://www.rsph.org.uk/en/policy-and-projects/areas-of-work/activity-equivalent-labelling/
5) http://m.jech.bmj.com
6) http://www.fsem.ac.uk/blog/posts/2014/october/include-the-views-of-many-when-planning-physical-activity-campaigns.aspx
7) http://www.fsem.ac.uk/blog/posts/2014/june/the-lay-view-is-physical-activity-available-to-all-children.aspx
8) http://blogs.bmj.com/bjsm/2016/01/14/its-national-obesity-awareness-week-and-now-more-than-ever-we-need-action/
9) http://www.fsem.ac.uk/media-resources/policy-and-public-affairs/obesity-stakeholder-group.aspx

SaveSave

My View on Activity Equivalents proposals from RSPH was last modified: March 11th, 2018 by Stephen Morrison
Activity equivalentsBan TelevisionsBMJBMJ BlogExercise EquivalentsFood labellingFSEMHowmanymilesJECHLay AdviserLay ViewObesityObesity Stakeholder GroupPhysical ActivityRoyal Society of Public HealthRunningStephen MorrisonWeight loss
2 comments
0
Facebook Twitter Google + Pinterest
previous post
CamGlen Radio’s Adventure Show TryBowls
Get Scotland Walking
next post
The Race is On. A Step Count Challenge

Some more posts that you might enjoy

World Obesity Day

World Obesity Day & the Soft Drink Industry

October 11, 2016

Win a Naipo Massage Cushion

February 19, 2018
dangerous coffee cup

What’s in Your Dangerous Coffee Cup: Convenience at What Cost?

September 15, 2024
walking my way to fitness

Walking My Way To Fitness

June 1, 2025

Using Activity Trackers to Get Scotland Walking

March 15, 2016

Tough New Rules from the Committee of Advertising Practice?

December 8, 2016
Top Tips For Coping With Your Sports Injury

Top Tips For Coping With Your Sports Injury

December 14, 2016
Avoid Winter Weight Gain

Tis the Season to Get Fit

December 1, 2022

Time to Come Clean

January 29, 2015
Thrive: Feel Stress Free

Thrive: Feel Stress Free Review and Offer

December 6, 2017

2 comments

Idaintyit April 18, 2016 at 8:02 am

I agree with you completely, whilst I can see the point of it I don’t really think it will stop anyone from eating what they want. Look at the health warnings on cigarette packets, they are awful and yet I still see teenagers start smoking!

Reply
Stephen Morrison April 24, 2016 at 9:46 pm

I hope we are both wrong, Hannah, but I fear that we will be proven correct

Reply

Leave a Comment Cancel Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Once 354lbs, I now use physical activity to add years to my life and life to my years

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google +
  • Instagram
  • Linkedin
  • Youtube
  • Email
  • Bloglovin
  • About HowManyMiles – From Morbid Obesity to Try Athlete and Active Traveller

@2016 - How Many Miles


Back To Top